Unravelling Australia’s Tax Conundrum: A Call for Reform
Pina Brandi • January 16, 2024

Most people trying to get into the property market usually blame the current Tax system.


They believe that property prices are the way they are because investors drive prices up and are supported by Tax benefits, however if those tax benefits were not there they wouldn’t buy properties.


A very interesting paper came from The Grattan Institute that talks about a tax reform and what would that do the property prices in Australia. 


The Grattan Institute is an independent think-tank focused on Australian public policy.


Here is my overview of the paper, however if you wish to read the full paper here is the link.


HOT PROPERTY


Australia’s tax landscape is in need of a significant overhaul. 


The interplay of a hefty fifty per cent capital gains tax (CGT) discount with negative gearing distorts investment decisions, amplifies housing market volatility, and hampers home ownership. 


Understanding the Current Scenario:


The existing tax breaks, particularly the CGT discount and negative gearing, favour the affluent, allowing them to curtail personal income tax at an annual cost of $11 billion to the public purse. 


These measures have fostered a system that benefits the wealthy, leading to imbalances in investment decisions and housing market dynamics.


Rationale for Reform:


The CGT discount, initially designed to preserve incentives for saving and investing, has inadvertently led to overcompensation for inflation among investors. 


The policy, though well-intentioned, has tilted too heavily in favour of protecting savings, sacrificing broader economic considerations. 


The report suggests that revising the CGT discount to 25 per cent strikes a better balance, addressing competing considerations and boosting Commonwealth Government tax revenue by $3.7 billion annually.


Negative Gearing Complexities:


Negative gearing, a practice allowing investors to use losses to reduce tax on wages and salaries, deviates from international norms. 


This system primarily benefits high-income individuals, diverting capital from more productive investments. 


The report advocates for aligning Australia with global practices, ceasing to deduct losses from passive investments from labour income. 


This change is expected to generate $2 billion annually in the short term.


Impact on Housing Affordability:


The proposed changes aim to enhance housing affordability, albeit modestly. Estimations suggest that prices could be up to 2 per cent lower than the status quo. 


While rents and new development rates are not anticipated to witness significant shifts, the effects on land prices could be more pronounced due to constraints on urban housing supply.


Phasing in Change:


Recognizing the potential for price shocks, the report recommends a phased approach to implementation. 


This not only cushions the impact on the market but also makes the reforms more palatable to the public. 


This approach is favoured over grandfathering current holdings, as it avoids complexity, accelerates additional tax collection, and promotes fairness to new investors.


Conclusion:


Australia stands at a crossroads in its tax policy, and the proposed reforms offer a path toward a more equitable and economically sound system. 


While the changes might not revolutionise the housing market, they represent a step toward correcting imbalances and fostering a fairer financial landscape. 


As discussions on tax reform intensify, the hope is that policymakers will consider the long-term benefits these changes can bring to the Australian economy.


Make sure you check out my series about how did we get here on property prices.


share to

By Pina Brandi July 14, 2025
While the headlines might suggest doom and gloom, Melbourne is far from down and out. In fact, this moment of weakness may well be the turning point — the stage in the cycle where the city’s long-term fundamentals quietly gather momentum again. If you’ve been waiting for the right time to buy in Melbourne, 2025 could be your moment. Key Reasons Melbourne Is Still Attractive for Property Investors Market Recovery Signs: After a period of decline in 2024, Melbourne has posted several consecutive months of home price growth in 2025. This signals a market turnaround, with prices still below their previous peaks, offering a countercyclical opportunity for investors. Strong Population Growth: Melbourne continues to experience robust population growth, driving long-term housing demand. Migration has ramped up, supporting both the rental and sales markets. Undersupply of New Homes: Building approvals are at record lows, and there is a shortage of new dwellings. This supply constraint, combined with rising demand, is expected to place upward pressure on prices over the coming years. Infrastructure Investment: Ongoing investment in transport, schools, and amenities across Melbourne’s growth corridors is enhancing liveability and supporting property values. Affordability Relative to Other Capitals: Melbourne’s median home price is now lower than Sydney and some other capitals, making it more accessible for investors and first-home buyers. Interest Rate Cuts: Recent interest rate reductions in 2025 have improved buyer sentiment and affordability, helping to fuel renewed activity in the property market. Long-Term Growth Fundamentals: Melbourne’s diversified economy, strong employment hubs, and lifestyle appeal underpin its reputation as a resilient, long-term investment destination. Where Are the Opportunities? For those looking to enter the market now, focus on areas where fundamentals still stack up — even in a down market.
By Pina Brandi July 7, 2025
Melbourne’s market may be down, but it’s not out. Discover why 2025 could be the best time to invest before the next property cycle begins.
By Pina Brandi June 20, 2025
Especially for the LGBTIQA+ Community
Show More